Vendan Ananda Kumararajah warns that unclear AI rules, unfair assessments, and weak oversight are eroding students' trust in university degrees. He outlines the risks and what institutions can do to rebuild confidence.
Vendan Ananda Kumararajah has a message for universities: if you don't get AI rules right, students will stop trusting your degrees. And he's not mincing words.
Kumararajah, a voice in the conversation around AI in education, points to three problems that are eroding confidence: unclear AI policies, unfair assessments, and weak oversight. "When students see inconsistency, they start to question the value of their qualifications," he warns.
That's a big deal. Because trust is the currency of higher education. Once it's gone, it's hard to win back.
### The Problem with Vague AI Policies
Many universities have rushed out AI guidelines that are either too vague or too strict. Students are left guessing what's allowed and what's not. One professor might ban AI entirely, while another encourages it. That inconsistency creates confusion and resentment.
"Students aren't against AI," Kumararajah says. "They're against unfairness."
And when the rules are unclear, students who play by the book feel penalized while others might slip through the cracks. That's a recipe for distrust.
### Unfair Assessments Undermine Confidence
AI has made it easier to cheat, but it's also made it harder to assess fairly. Some universities have responded by doubling down on traditional exams, while others have embraced AI-resistant assignments. But without clear standards, students worry that their grades don't reflect their true abilities.
Kumararajah argues that assessments should be redesigned to focus on process, not just product. "If we only grade the final output, we're missing the point," he says. "We need to evaluate how students think, not just what they produce."
### Weak Oversight Leads to Mistrust
Finally, oversight is often an afterthought. Universities may have policies on paper, but enforcement is inconsistent. Without proper monitoring, students see AI rules as toothless. And that breeds cynicism.
"Students are smart," Kumararajah notes. "They know when rules are just for show. And they lose respect for institutions that don't follow through."
### What Universities Can Do
So what's the fix? Kumararajah suggests a few practical steps:
- **Create clear, consistent policies** that apply across all departments.
- **Involve students in the conversation**—they're the ones most affected.
- **Provide training for faculty** so they can enforce rules fairly.
- **Invest in assessment redesign** that accounts for AI use.
- **Establish transparent oversight** with real consequences.
> "Trust is built on consistency and fairness," Kumararajah says. "If universities can get that right, they'll not only keep students' trust—they'll prepare them for a world where AI is everywhere."
The stakes are high. Universities that fail to act risk more than just unhappy students—they risk their reputation. And in a competitive landscape, that's a price no institution can afford.
As Kumararajah puts it: "Students are watching. And they're taking notes."