Why Unclear AI Rules Could Cost Universities Student Trust
Jan de Vries ยท
Listen to this article~3 min
Kumararajah warns that vague AI policies, unfair assessments, and weak oversight are eroding student trust in university degrees. Here's what's at stake and what schools can do.
Students are starting to ask a question that should worry every university leader: if I can't tell what's allowed with AI, how do I know my degree actually means something?
Vendan Ananda Kumararajah is raising that alarm directly. His warning is blunt. Unclear AI policies, assessments that feel unfair, and weak oversight are quietly eroding the trust students place in their qualifications. And once that trust slips, it's hard to win back.
### The Real Problem Isn't AI. It's the Silence Around It.
Most universities didn't plan to be here. AI tools arrived fast, and institutions scrambled to respond. Some banned them outright. Others looked the other way. A few wrote policies so vague that nobody, including the professors, could say what counted as cheating.
That ambiguity lands on students. Two people submit similar work. One gets flagged, the other doesn't. A student uses a tool for brainstorming and gets accused of misconduct. Another uses it to write an entire essay and slips through. When the rules are fuzzy, outcomes start to feel random. And random feels unfair.
> "Trust isn't built on perfect rules. It's built on rules students can actually understand and see applied consistently."
### Fairness Is the Currency Here
Students accept hard work. They accept high standards. What they struggle with is inconsistency. If assessment rules shift by course, by professor, or by mood, the degree starts to feel less like a credential and more like a gamble.
Kumararajah's point cuts deeper than policy compliance. It's about legitimacy. Employers, graduate schools, and the students themselves all need to believe the degree reflects real capability. Weak oversight undermines that belief from the inside.
### What Universities Should Actually Do
- Write AI policies in plain language students can read in five minutes
- Apply the same standards across departments, not just within them
- Train faculty to spot AI use fairly, not suspiciously
- Give students a clear path to appeal when a call feels wrong
- Publish outcomes so people can see the rules working in practice
None of this is glamorous. It's the unglamorous work that keeps institutions credible.
### The Stakes Are Bigger Than One Semester
The trust problem compounds. A student who feels wrongly accused tells friends. Word spreads. Prospective applicants notice. Rankings and reputation follow slowly, then all at once.
Universities have a narrow window here. Get the rules clear and fair now, and AI becomes a tool students use responsibly. Get it wrong, and the degree itself starts to look uncertain, which is the last thing any institution wants to explain to a future employer.