The Quiet Investors Who Spot Europe's Next Unicorns First

ยท
Listen to this article~5 min

Famous funds get the headlines, but small emerging managers often spot Europe's biggest startups first. Here's why the quietest backers see the most.

Every quarter I read the reports from the fund managers we back, and I keep asking the same question: who spotted this company first? It's rarely a famous name. In January 2023, ElevenLabs announced a $2.2 million pre-Seed round led by Credo Ventures. Alongside it was Concept Ventures, a London firm that had launched its first institutional fund, worth about $62 million, the year before. ElevenLabs was that fund's very first investment. By late 2026, ElevenLabs had sold roughly $287 million of shares at a valuation north of $20 billion. Back in 2023, few people outside early-stage circles had heard of Concept. This piece is about the gap between when someone sees a company and when everyone else does. ### Why the first backers stay out of sight These investors are hard to see for two reasons. The first is attention. In the first half of 2026, Andreessen Horowitz, Thrive Capital and Founders Fund raised 48% of all US venture fund capital between them. In Europe, emerging managers, firms on their first few funds, took 52.8% of the roughly $8.9 billion raised by VC funds in the same period. Yet the press still follows the big rounds and the billion-dollar funds. The second reason is who funds them. According to the ECB, government bodies such as the European Investment Fund make up around a third of the investors in EU venture funds. That's roughly eight times their share in the US. Many of those backers want years of track record, which a first fund simply cannot show. So the managers who find companies first are often the last to be noticed. Around 1,000 fund managers applied to us in the last 12 months. Since August, about two thirds have pitched pre-Seed strategies, up from half before the summer. Managers in France, Italy and the UK told us the same thing: back local founders early, while prices are low. For a small fund, the earliest stage is where it can win. ### Why small funds see first A $62 million fund like Concept's can't make its returns in expensive later rounds. Its checks are too small to matter there. It has to buy a real stake before others notice a company, and be right. In the Nordics, an early backer of Lovable was The Nordic Web Ventures, a roughly $5.4 million pre-Seed fund run by a single partner, Neil Murray. With no committee to convince, he can invest before there is proof. Full disclosure: we are investors in his fund. Carta's data shows what that looks like at the top. Among funds that started investing in 2018, the best 10% of those under about $9.7 million reached a total value to paid-in capital (TVPI) of 4.03x. That means $4.03 of value for every dollar invested. The best 10% of funds above roughly $97 million reached just 1.67x. I call the period in which this happens the signal window: the time when someone who knows a field can judge a company, but the wider market can't yet. ElevenLabs was inside that window in early 2023. Today everyone can see it, and the price shows it. Europe keeps the window open for longer, mostly because of price. ### Why Europe gives small funds room It has been reported that the median pre-money valuation of a European AI startup in the first half of 2026 was about $9 million, against roughly $69 million in the US. At those prices, a 10% stake costs about $970,000 in Europe and about $7.5 million in the US. A $54 million fund can buy that stake dozens of times in Europe, and only seven times in the US. > "The managers who find companies first are often the last to be noticed." ### Where this goes wrong None of this makes every small fund a good bet. Venture returns follow a power law: a few companies produce most of the gains, and the same is true of funds. The figures above describe the best small funds, not the typical one. Cash also comes back at very different speeds. By early 2026, fewer than half of the funds Carta tracks from 2019 and 2020 had returned any cash to their investors. The strongest small funds tend to pay out sooner, because they need cash returns to raise their next fund. Cambridge Associates, for one, now asks managers to show distributions before it commits again. Weaker funds have nothing to sell. So the next time you read about a hot startup, look past the headline names. Ask who wrote the first check. That's where the real story usually sits, quietly waiting to be noticed.