If AI Marketing Is Easy for You, It's Easy for Everyone

ยท
Listen to this article~5 min

AI made content cheap for everyone, not just you. Here's why the easiest AI marketing win is actually the wrong one, and what still builds trust with buyers.

Everybody's first instinct with AI in marketing is content. Write my posts. Draft my newsletter. Fire off personalized cold emails. Spin up hundreds of avatar videos so I never have to sit in front of a camera again. Build ad creatives while I sleep. It looks like the easiest win. But the logic of the attention economy says the opposite: this is exactly the wrong place to start. ### "We did it with AI" tells you almost nothing That sentence never describes the actual work. If an agent did everything from a few prompts, the output is probably bad. If you were deeply involved but coded it with AI, great โ€” but you just did the same thing faster. Marketing is still marketing. The same old rules apply. If you don't know those rules, no model is going to save you. Personalization is the perfect example. Amazon has been showing people feeds based on their shopping habits for well over a decade. That's not art. It isn't new either. AI is basically the poor man's data science here. What's new is that a good professional can now do it faster and at scale. And an incompetent one can do their thing faster too. So I think of AI as an amplifier. It makes bigger whatever is already there. And contrary to popular belief, content was never really about the writing, the copy, or the visuals. It's about whether you know what to say, how, and to whom. Miss that, and AI just helps you make more slop. You won't even notice, because it looks good enough. The results never come, though. (Unless your whole goal is entertaining AI brainrot. Edge case.) ### Free for you means free for everyone Here's a simple supply and demand view. The cost of everyday content, or of a personalized cold email, dropped to zero for you. It dropped to zero for everyone else too. Do what they do and you have no advantage at all. Worse, your buyers start to find it off-putting. With personalized outreach, you can already see it. People's shields are up. If you can do it, everyone can. When everyone does, the buyer gets fed up and personalization stops being worth anything. - Average cold email reply rates fell from 5.1% in 2024 to 3.43% in 2026 - Many AI sales outreach agencies grow fast, then stall โ€” churn kills them because the method doesn't work consistently for their clients - UGC ad agency Icon, backed by Founders Fund and OpenAI's chief research officer, reportedly paid $12 million for its domain and launched as "the world's first AI CMO" โ€” today it sells ads made by human creators, "no AI / 100% real" That's a 180-degree turn. And it should tell you something. ### The signs of AI use are there The average answer is: fine, then make sure nobody notices it's AI. But right now, if you pretend your output is 100% original, purely human creation, nobody believes you. The signs are there. Sure, in six months or a year the models will be good enough that those signs vanish. Maybe we're already there with video. But they'll be gone for everyone else too. Then what? That channel is dead. So what's left? > The CEO dinners. Referrals. Borrowed credibility from brands that already have it โ€” micro influencers included. Things that don't scale linearly. Or just raw, unfiltered, unhinged human creativity. Those are the directions I think will gain ground again. Because in the end, it's about trust. If you want to use AI heavily in front of customers to save time, fine โ€” go all the way. Make it your thing. Make it extremely entertaining. Everyone will know, and it won't matter, because you owned it. What won't work is hiding. The moment your AI output looks like everyone else's AI output, you've handed your buyers a reason to scroll past. The plays that still land are the ones a prompt can't manufacture: a relationship, a reputation, a genuinely strange idea. Those don't come free. That's the point.